Moving premium dollars faster keeps cash flowing and coverage bound, but what happens when payments show up without the data to match them?
The insurance industry has spent years trying to speed up premium payments, and for good reason. Between paper checks, lengthy remittance cycles, and the occasional payment that seems to disappear into the accounting abyss, there’s plenty of room for improvement.
Think back to that classic science-class photo of an iceberg (you know the one). There’s a small tip visible above the surface, and a massive, hidden chunk underneath doing all the heavy lifting. When it comes to insurance payments, speed is the tip everyone talks about. The data problem sitting beneath the surface is what’s actually weighing teams down.
“We’ve gotten better at moving money electronically, but we haven’t gotten quite as good at making sure the information needed to reconcile it comes along, too.”
A payment can arrive in seconds and still take hours to reconcile. An insured can pay their agent on time, only for the MGA to receive the funds weeks later; and a completely legitimate payment can stall out while an entire accounting team hunts down the policy it belongs to.
During Insurance Insider’s recent roundtable, Rethinking Premium Payments: The Insurance Industry’s Strategic Lever, leaders from ePayPolicy, Amwins, Arden Insurance Services, and Lawley unpacked why payment modernization is about more than getting money from point A to point B.
Yes, the money should be moving fast, but the real test is making sure the remittance data and the systems reading it actually move together.
Same Policy. Different Systems. Plenty of Room for Things to Break.
Let’s follow a premium dollar for a moment:
- An insured pays their agent.
- The agent remits net premium to an MGA or wholesaler.
- The MGA settles with the carrier.
Depending on the transaction, there may be even more stops along the way. This process is simple enough on paper, except each organization has its own systems, accounting processes, and way of identifying that same policy.
What one system calls Policy 12345 might look entirely different in the next. And when payment information doesn’t translate between those systems, someone has to step in and connect the dots.
Digital Payments vs. Intelligent Payments
Mark Engels, CEO of ePayPolicy, described the distinction between simply accepting digital payments and what he calls intelligent payments: transactions that carry the information needed to automatically reconcile them within an organization’s management system.
It’s an important distinction. Because collecting a payment digitally doesn’t automatically eliminate the manual work that follows. Without the right integrations and remittance data, accounting teams still have to identify deposits, match invoices, and figure out where everything belongs.
This leaves us in a place where the insurance industry has essentially made it possible for money to travel at digital speed while leaving some of the paperwork stuck in limbo.
You Didn’t Eliminate the Manual Work, You Just Forwarded It
One of the more interesting perspectives came from Judy Lyon, EVP of Accounting Operations at Amwins. She pointed out that the payment experience that’s easiest for one organization can create more work for another.
Consider a large agency using an established accounts payable system. It has approval workflows, internal controls, and a process for issuing payments. Asking that agency to leave its system and log into a separate portal might make reconciliation easier for the recipient, but it introduces more steps for the payer.
On the other hand, allowing the agency to send money directly from its own system may be more convenient for them, while leaving the receiving organization to reconstruct what the payment was for.
The manual work hasn’t just suddenly disappeared; it just changed hands. And in an industry where one organization’s receivable is another organization’s payable, that’s a pretty important detail.
It also raises a bigger question: are we actually eliminating inefficiencies, or just passing them down the distribution chain?
For years, payment modernization has largely focused on improving individual transactions. But there’s ample opportunity to connect the entire process so each organization doesn’t have to solve the same problem independently.
Wishful Thinking Won’t Kill the Paper Check
As much as we’d all love to declare paper checks dead, the insurance industry keeps proving they can outlive their predictions. Despite years of digital payment innovation, checks still account for a significant portion of premium collections.
During the roundtable, panelists shared their organizations’ approximate check volumes:
- Arden Insurance Services: ~40% of monthly payments
- Amwins: ~20% of payments
- Lawley: 900 of approximately 1,200 monthly payments (~75% of monthly payments)
That’s a lot of envelopes, deposits, and reconciliation.
Why Checks Are Still Circulating
Some checks come from customers who prefer traditional payment methods. Others originate from sophisticated enterprise accounts payable systems that generate checks as part of their existing workflows. In other words, the organizations sending checks aren’t always the ones stuck in the dark ages.
And while encouraging digital adoption remains important, expecting every payer to jump ship on their established processes isn’t particularly realistic.
“Payment modernization needs to account for the payments organizations actually receive, not just the ones they’d prefer to receive.”
Tools like optical character recognition (OCR), integrations, and machine learning can help extract information from checks and supporting documents, match payments to outstanding receivables, and reduce the amount of manual intervention required.
If checks are going to stay in the mix, capturing that data automatically saves accounting teams from keying in details line by line, which eats up hours and invites avoidable typos.
How to Grow 20x Without Adding a Single AR Hire
Manual reconciliation is inevitably a growth ceiling just as much as it is an admin thorn in your side. As insurance organizations increase premium volume, their accounting workloads grow with them. More transactions mean more deposits to reconcile, more exceptions to investigate, and more opportunities for something to go seriously wrong.
Unless, of course, the process itself becomes more efficient.
Decoupling Growth from Headcount
During the roundtable, Tyler Diogo, Operations Manager at Arden Insurance Services shared that the organization has scaled approximately 20 times while maintaining just two employees handling accounts receivable, thanks in part to technology and automation.
That number alone is worth a double take, and it proves what happens when you decouple growth from headcount. Tyler described it as “automating people into better jobs.”
Instead of spending hours opening checks, entering information, and matching payments, employees can focus on exceptions, higher-level analysis, and work that actually benefits from their expertise.
Judy reinforced that distinction, noting that while technology can handle repetitive reconciliation tasks, human judgment remains essential for looking into discrepancies, maintaining internal controls, and solving more complex problems.
In an industry increasingly obsessed with AI, that distinction matters. Good automation leaves people in the driver's seat and simply clears out the repetitive work slowing them down. After all, hiring more people to manually reconcile a growing number of payments isn’t much of a scalability strategy—it’s just a more expensive version of the same problem.
Who’s Protecting the Policyholder from Cancellation?
Yes, inefficient payment workflows create problems for accounting teams, but the downstream consequences for the insured are also driving urgency around modernization.
During the discussion, Mark shared a finding from ePayPolicy’s platform: Approximately 40% of observed net premium payments from agents to MGAs were late.
The Ripple Effect of Delayed Payments
That’s a dramatic number, particularly when you consider what happens next. An insured pays their agent and reasonably assumes their payment has been handled, but the net premium doesn’t reach the MGA on time.
Now the MGA is following up on an outstanding receivable, the agent is trying to track down the payment, and the insured may receive a notice of cancellation for coverage they believe they’ve already paid for. Not exactly the customer experience anyone was hoping to deliver.
What started as a payment delay has become an operational issue for multiple organizations, and potentially a very stressful situation for the policyholder.
“Payment speed and payment intelligence aren’t competing priorities. They’re two parts of the same problem.”
Moving money faster helps reduce delays. Making sure that money arrives with the right information helps the receiving organization identify, reconcile, and process it without creating another roadblock. The short of it is, speed gets money there; data makes it usable.
Easy Payments Get Money In. Connected Data Keeps it Moving.
Digital payment adoption still matters. Faster settlement still matters. And reducing the industry’s reliance on paper checks is still a worthwhile goal. But none of those improvements fully solve the problem if every organization receiving a payment has to figure out what to do with it.
The next opportunity is connecting the movement of money with the movement of data. That means:
- Capturing accurate remittance information earlier
- Integrating with existing management systems
- Creating more continuity as premium dollars move between agents, MGAs, wholesalers, and carriers
It also means acknowledging that there probably won’t be one perfect system that handles every financial workflow for every organization.
Eliminating Blind Spots Across Tools
During the roundtable, panelists discussed the challenges of consolidating invoicing, payments, commissions, and payables into a single platform. For some organizations, that may make sense. For others, specialized systems that communicate effectively may be the better approach.
What truly moves the needle is eliminating the blind spots between your tools, even if you keep using more than one. With AI and machine learning making it easier to interpret unstructured payment data, identify patterns, and automate reconciliation, the technology to address those disconnects is becoming more and more sophisticated.
As much as we’d love to tack new software onto a broken workflow, dust our hands off, and call it modernization, it rarely works out that way. Those tools only pay off when they are built to handle the gaps across the entire payment chain, not just inside one organization.
Faster is Good. Connected is Better.
For an industry built around managing risk, we spend a surprising amount of time managing preventable payment problems:
- Checks that take way too long to arrive.
- Payments that show up without enough information.
- Accounting teams chasing down discrepancies.
- Customers wondering why they’ve received a cancellation notice after already paying their premium.
None of these challenges exist in isolation, and solving them one transaction at a time only gets us so far. There’s an exciting opportunity here to think bigger about what happens to a premium payment from the moment it’s collected to the moment it’s settled.
Real progress means getting money to the next organization faster, with the right information attached, so the next accounting team can reconcile it right away. Once the data moves just as smoothly as the dollars, payment modernization actually delivers on its promise.







